Property Types  Retail
Is East Asia's Vertical Retail Model Wave of Future for U.S.?
Jul 22, 2009
By: Barbra Murray, Conributing Editor

Vertical retailing--building retail destinations higher instead of wider--has long been a success in cities like Hong Kong and Shanghai, but the trend has yet to catch on in the United States. However, given the country's growing population and dwindling pool of developable land in major cities, the time may be just right for the nation's metropolises to jump on the bandwagon, or so believes Charles Chan, president of commercial real estate brokerage firm Harvest International.

"It's a good model for places like New York, Chicago and San Francisco, where it's very densely populated and there's a limited amount of space," Chan told CPN. "I think this is a very timely model for future retailing because not only is space limited but rent, even though it's declining with the downtown of the economy, it's still expensive. So the only way to go is up... and going up, you can have an atrium, a level for food, a level for women's wear, a level for menswear--it's very easy to configure."

Indeed, the vertical retail premise has proven to be a winning endeavor in some major cities overseas. As real estate services firm Colliers International notes in a research paper on vertical retailing in Hong Kong, for retailers that rely on repeat clients--and are not dependent on the exposure a street-front location provides--the upper-floor retail unit is the most appropriate environment. Among the types of retailers that benefit the most from the arrangement are food and beverage businesses, salons and spas and learning centers.

The vertical mall concept certainly provides economic advantages for the retailer, but it presents coveted benefits for the shopper, too. "Nowadays when transportation is so expensive, you can shop and get your groceries at the same place," Chan said. "It's an easier way of living, and it's more cost effective. Additionally, it will work very well in very severe weather; you don't want to drive around and risk chances of getting in a traffic jam or getting hit by a car."

Harvest International is in the process of putting its money where its mouth is. The firm is planning to convert the former Caldor Department store building near Main Street and Roosevelt Avenue in Flushing, N.Y., into a vertical shopping center mecca. The 240,000-square-foot structure, located practically atop a subway terminal and fronting a bevy of bus lines, features four floors for retail space and a two-level underground parking facility. The project, tentatively named New World Mall, is expected to feature everything from a "hyper mega food mart" to a children's play center. "If you are a mother with a child and have only two hours to do your shopping, you can go to a vertical retailing location and within two hours, you can get things done without wasting gas," Chan explained. "You could pick up your groceries, pick up your child and get in and out."

Interior plans for New World Mall are currently being finalized, and once that activity is wrapped up, interior renovation of the building will commence, with a target completion date for early spring of 2010. Already, Chan said, "we've had lots of interest from retailers."

 
Recent Retail Headlines
W.P. Carey Keeps Eye on Europe with $90M Sale-Leaseback in Hungary
Net lease real estate firm W.P. Carey & Co. has been looking to amp up its activity on the international scene of late, and the latest move by the firm is a big step in that direction.
General Growth Names Rufrano to Board
General Growth Properties Inc. named Glenn Rufrano to its board of directors. Rufrano is CEO of Centro Properties Group, a role he was appointed to in January 2008, leading it through a difficult restructuring effort. Australia-based Centro threatened to be an early victim of the credit crisis. Rufrano had been heading the shopping center company's U.S. operations, having served as longtime CEO of New Plan Excel Realty Trust Inc. before Centro purchased the public REIT in 2000. General Growth filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection earlier this year.
Opus Property Services Reported for Sale
Opus Corp. is seeking to sell its property-management business, according to a report on bizjournals.com, the Web site of American City Business Journals. It quoted a company spokesperson as stating that selling off Opus Property Services would help the company renew its focus on its "core competency," along with its being a good time to sell because property management firms currently have an "appetite ... to grow their (business)." Opus' management portfolio totals about 30 million square feet of office, retail, industrial and corporate space.
Economic Update - CalPERS Takes Rating Agencies to Task
Another California trend? CalPERS, the nation's largest pension fund, has filed suit against the three largest credit-ratingsagencies, essentially asserting that the agencies gave away highratings like gold stars to kindergartners back in the days when realestate only went up. Or to use the language of the lawsuit, "wildlyinaccurate and unreasonably high" ratings on various structuredinvestment vehicles caused the pension fund to lose a cool billiondollars.
Opus Group Bankruptcy Filings Mount
The struggling economy is making its mark on Minnetonka, Minn.,-based Opus Group which now has a number of its subsidiaries filing for bankruptcy. So far, Opus West Corp. and Opus South Corp. have filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy. Opus East, meanwhile, has filed Chapter 7. Austin’s Hill Country Galleria, developed by Opus West, filed for Chapter 11, too.
U.S. Chain Store Sales Down 5% in July
Leaner inventories and a shift in state sales-tax holidays hampered U.S. chain store sales in July, which were off 5 percent on a same-store basis, compared with the same period last year, according to the International Council of Shopping Centers.
NPD: U.S. Restaurant Traffic Posts Steepest Decline in 28 Years
Still feeling the impact of rising unemployment and thrifty consumers, restaurant traffic in the spring quarter ended May 2009, posted the sharpest decline in the industry since 1981, according to market research company The NPD Group.
Economic Update: On Cars, Gas and Lipstick Sales
Closely watched retail figures from the National Retail Federation show that June retail sales took a small dip of 0.2 percent when compared to May, and were down 3.8 percent when compared to June 2008. These figures differed somewhat from those of the U.S. Department of Commerce, which released its own retail sales figures last week that showed a slight improvement in sales in June when compared with May--growth of 0.6 percent. The difference is that Commerce includes cars, gasoline and restaurant sales, . In fact, the only category to have grown since this time last year was health and personal care stores, up 3.7 percent since 2008. Could it be due to the "lipstick effect"?
Economic Update - Fast-Track Chrysler Reorganization Stalls
The Chrysler reorganization and sale to Fiat, which was to have been a model of a quick turn-around, has hit a snag in the form of a court order by U.S. Supreme Court Associate Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. Pension funds that hold some of Chrysler’s secured loan are objecting to the goings-on, claiming it isn’t fair to them, and so petitioned Justice Ginsburg for the measure. It isn’t clear how long the temporary stay will delay the sale, or whether it will kill the sale, or whether the full court will reverse the stay in a few days. It’s unlikely, though, that the legal wrangling will affect the fate of the Chrysler dealerships slated for closing, or change the amount of real estate their closing will put on the market.
Economic Update - Starwood Eyes Distressed Sector with $500M Fund
Yet another deep-pocketed real estate entity has jumped into the grave-dancing game—only please, don’t call it that, but rather strategic investment in distressed properties. The player is a newly formed investment company called Starwood Property Trust Inc., a creation of Starwood mogul Barry Sternlicht, which filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission late last week for a public offering that aims to raise half a billion dollars to do the distressed-property boogie. It will invest in not only physical properties, but mortgages and mortgage-backed securities.
Economic Update - CMBS Delinquencies Spike
U.S. Commercial mortgage-backed securities delinquencies grew in June by a record $2.2 billion, according to Fitch Ratings. Last month there was a 2.6 percent delinquency rate among U.S. CMBS, up 48 basis points from the previous month. In June, at least, problems in retail properties and the hospitality industry inspired much of the upward bounce in delinquencies. But there's more to come, especially in the beleaguered hotel sector.
Economic Update - Legacy CMBS Now Under TALF
In a major expansion of the Term Asset Backed Securities Loan Facility (TALF), the Federal Reserve said on Tuesday that investors will be able to buy existing securities backed by commercial real estate loans--so-called "legacy" CMBS. The commercial real estate industry has been pushing for this for some time, and it will at last be possible starting in July.
Economic Update - Tesco Completes Sale-Leaseback, CMBS Deals
British retailer Tesco Plc. inked a sale-leaseback of 14 properties. The sale-leaseback followed on the heels of the company's successful completion of the sale of commercial mortgage-backed securities. The offering by Tesco may mark the glimmering beginnings of a new, simpler CMBS market.
RaceTrac Initiates Sale-Leaseback Program
RaceTrac Petroleum Inc., which owns and operates 530 convenience stores and gas stations in 12 states, has tapped CB Richard Ellis Inc.'s global corporate services unit to exclusively manage a sale/leaseback program..
1.1MSF SoCal Mall Trades for Reported $50M
The 1.1 million-square-foot South Bay Pavilion retail complex in the South Bay area of Los Angeles has sold for a reported $50 million.
With Robust Retail Demand on the Horizon, Work Begins on $100M Shopping Center at Fort Bliss
Development in the retail sector, which began its nosedive with the collapse of the housing and credit markets, is hardly booming. However, the situation is quite different at Fort Bliss in El Paso County, Texas, where the Base Realignment and Closure Act of 2005 will bring an estimated 127,000 new military personnel and family members to the area by 2012.
Economic Update - Green Shoots a Little Greener, but CRE Not Overjoyed
It was a good way to start the week, economically speaking. According to the Conference Board, the U.S. index of leading economic indicators rose 0.7 percent in June, marking the third rise in the index in as many months. In the first half of 2009, the index improved at an annualized rate of some 4.1 percent , a clear contrast to the way it shrank in the last half of 2008 at an annualized rate of 6.2 percent.
Q2 Demand as Weak as Expected Across Sectors--Except M-F
The dismal economy continued its stranglehold on the commercial real estate industry, as per CBRE Econometric Advisors' recently released analysis, pushing up vacancies in the office, industrial and retail property markets. But there was one surprise. Demand in the multi-family sector, despite the ongoing job losses that are hindering the formation of new households, was essentially unchanged from the first quarter of the year.
Economic Update - Homebuilding Unexpectedly Perks Up, For Now
The residential market made a surprising turn on Friday, with the U.S. Department of Commerce reporting that housing starts were up 3.6 percent in June when compared with May: an annualized total of 582,000 units versus 562,000 units. Economists weren’t expecting that many.
Cadillac Fairview Buys 49% Interest in NY Macerich Center
Cadillac Fairview Corp. purchased a 49 percent interest in Macerich's Queens Center in the New York City borough of Queens for $150 million in net cash. The eighth joint venture between the two firms, the venture gives Canadian Cadillac Fairview, wholly owned by the Ontario Teachers' Pension Plan, entree to New York City. Queens Center is the top-performing asset in Macerich's portfolio: The 966,499-square-foot urban retail center, which at year-end 2008 was 97.5 percent occupied, was at that time producing annual mall sales of $876 per square foot. Macerich purchased it in 1995 and redeveloped and expanded it in 2004.
Economic Update: Retailers Term CIT Too Big to Fail; TALF Attracts Interest
As if the retail industry didn't have enough trouble, the prospect of a CIT Group bankruptcy is blowing through the industry like an unexpected squall. On Thursday, those new worries were reflected in the S&P Retail Index, which fell 0.8 percent. If CIT does go under, many smaller and mid-sized apparel retailers might also have trouble staying afloat later this year, especially during the critical holiday season.
CalPERS-First Washington JV to Replace Macquarie in Partnership with Regency Centers
Macquarie CountryWide Trust agreed to sell the majority of its interest in Macquarie CountryWide-Regency II L.L.C., a four-year-old partnership with Regency Centers Corp. that owns  86 retail shopping centers valued at $1.7 billion, to Global Retail Investors L.L.C. , a joint venture between the California Public Employees' Retirement System and an affiliate of First Washington Realty Inc. The phased sale will result in Global Retail Investors owning 60 percent of the partnership, with Regency having the option to increase its ownership from 25 percent to 40 percent. Otherwise, the remaining interest would be sold to Global Retail Investors or elsewhere, depending on two possible options.
Crossman to Handle Leasing for 10.4MSF Publix Portfolio
Third-party leasing and management firm Crossman & Co. has been named the exclusive leasing representatives for all Publix-owned retail properties in Florida, Georgia, Alabama, Tennessee and South Carolina.
Is East Asia's Vertical Retail Model Wave of Future for U.S.?
Vertical retailing--building retail destinations higher instead of wider--has long been a success in cities like Hong Kong and Shanghai, but the trend has yet to catch on in the United States. However, given the country's growing population and dwindling pool of developable land in major cities, the time may be just right for the nation's metropolises to jump on the bandwagon, or so believes Charles Chan, president of commercial real estate brokerage firm Harvest International.
Net-Leased CVS Property Trades in Illinois
Marcus & Millichap Real Estate Investment Services has arranged the sale of an 8,540-square-foot single-tenant net-leased property, located in Westville, Ill.
Eddie Bauer Latest Retailer to File for Bankruptcy
Clothing retailer Eddie Bauer Holdings Inc. has filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy, becoming the latest firm to be stung by the retail industry’s sharp downturn.
Economic Update - Consumer Spending, Saving Up; Will Retailers Benefit?
This might count as good news: U.S. consumer spending and personal income both rose in May. Spending jumped by a small but noticeable 0.3 percent when compared with April, and personal income spiked upward by 1.4 percent, the strongest jump in more than a year, according to the U.S. Department of Commerce. The question now for retailers and their landlords is how much of that is going to go toward buying things.
Filene's Basement Assets Snapped Up by Men's Wearhouse in $67M Auction
Clothing retailer Men's Wearhouse has emerged victorious from a feverish nine-hour auction of assets belonging to off-price chain Filene's Basement, which fell victim to the retail market's downward spiral and filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in early May, just two weeks after its purchase by Buxbaum Group affiliate FB Acquisition II. Acting through its affiliate, K&G Acquisition Corp., Men's Wearhouse put forth the winning bid of $67 million for 17 to 20 of Filene's store leases, as well as the leases on the company's Massachusetts corporate headquarters and distribution center, its Maryland storage facility and-- possibly most important--the Filene's Basement trade name.
JV Makes $25M Virginia Retail Play
A joint venture between Spectrum Partners L.L.C., Alex. Brown Realty Inc. and Potomac Capital Advisors, has acquired Westgate Plaza Shopping Center in Manassas, Va., for $25 million from Principal Real Estate Investors.
Philly Shopping Center Lands $17M in Financing
The New Jersey office of Holliday Fenoglio Fowler L.P. has secured $17 million in financing for Columbus Crossing, a 142,000-square-foot, grocery-anchored shopping center in Philadelphia.
Economic Update - Homebuyers Slowly Returning to Existing Home Market
Homebuyers seem to be returning to the existing-home market this summer, according to the latest report by the National Association of Realtors on existing U.S. housing sales. The sales of single-family homes, condos and coops rose 2.4 percent in May compared with April, coming on top of a gain for that month compared with March, thus marking the first back-to-back monthly increase in existing home sales since 2005.
Economic Update - Discount Retailers Still on Top
Even in a recession, there will be winners. Even in the retail world, which has taken such a beating lately, there will also be winners--such as Family Dollar Stores Inc., which reported its fiscal third-quarter numbers on Wednesday. Its earnings spiked upward by 36 percent, which the discount retailer attributed to strong sales of necessities. Comparable-store sales, an important metric in the retail game, were up 6.2 percent.
Economic Update - Christmas in July to Boost Retail Sales?
As expected, June was a lousy month for retail sales--except at a few retailers, probably including Wal-Mart Stores Inc., though the giant retailer doesn't report monthly comparable-store sales. Target Corp., on the other hand, reported a 6.2 percent comp-store drop from June 2008, while Costco Wholesale Corp. dropped 6 percent. Major department store chains took a comp-store drubbing as well: Nordstrom Inc., down 10 percent; Macy's, down 8.9 percent; J.C. Penney down 8.2 percent; Dillard's Inc. down 14 percent.
Economic Update - Spooked by Economy, Consumers Consume Less
The U.S. Department of Commerce reported that retail sales dropped by 0.4 percent in April, compared with the previous month. The decline was a little more than expected, but less than the revised March drop of 1.3 percent. The recent two months of decline followed unexpected increases in consumer spending in January and February.
Economic Update - Wal-Mart Takes Historic Healthcare Position, But Why?
It's a peculiar time in history when a retailer can influence the debate about national healthcare policy. Yet Wal-Mart is doing just that by coming out earlier this week in favor of the government forcing employers to provide health insurance to workers. It was seen as something of a surprise. The Wall Street Journal characterized the National Retail Federation as "flabbergasted" by Wal-Mart's decision. (Were NRF officials sitting around in conference rooms, being flabbergasted together?)
Economic Update - Retailers See May Malaise
May comparable-store sales numbers are filtering down from various retailers, and the results aren't inspiring confidence in the prospects for recovered consumer spending. Actually, most analysts expected average retail same-store sales to decline in May 2009 when compared with May 2008, but the trouble was they declined more than expected.
Redevelopment of Former Auto Dealerships a Tough Prospect
In May, both Chrysler and General Motors cut loose thousands of dealerships -- some 789 by Chrysler as part of its bankruptcy proceedings, and then about another 1,100 by GM even before its bankruptcy. The moves were part of the aggressive scaling back by both companies to meet the stipulations of the federal government's Auto Task Force.
Economic Update - Deutsche Bank Offers Grim View of U.S. Mortgages
Like a trailer for a monster movie, a new report by Deutsche Bank is promising scary things in the not-too-distant future. Assuming that housing prices continue a decline, the percentage of underwater mortgages might rise to 48 percent of the total, or roughly 25 million loans, by the first quarter of 2011. The bank is predicting that U.S. home prices will decline a further 14 percent from current prices by the first quarter of 2011.
Economic Update - Economists Call for Downsizing Financial Companies
If some esteemed economists testifying before the Joint Economic Committee of Congress Tuesday had their way, "too big to fail" would be a phrase of historical interest only--applying especially to that period of history just before 2008.
Retailers Caught in Limbo as Sale-Leasebacks Bring in Fewer Dollars
Beset by a still-icy lending climate, as well as continued weak fundamentals as a result of the global economic slump, cash-strapped retailers are increasingly finding themselves caught between a rock and a hard place when it comes to monetizing their real estate holdings via sale leaseback deals.