Finance  Net Leasing
Retailers Caught in Limbo as Sale-Leasebacks Bring in Fewer Dollars
Jul 07, 2009
By: Adam Perrotta, News Writer

Beset by a still-icy lending climate, as well as continued weak fundamentals as a result of the global economic slump, cash-strapped retailers are increasingly finding themselves caught between a rock and a hard place when it comes to monetizing their real estate holdings via sale leaseback deals.

That has not stalled the market completely, though, and several retailers are still finding sale-leaseback deals to their liking, despite the lower prices of today’s market.

Gone, of course, are the days when a retailer could make a quick windfall by selling off property at the premium prices of the boom market of years past. Indeed, the very same financial forces plaguing the retail business—which has seen a rash of bankruptcies over the past few months—are also limiting the prices that prospective real estate buyers are willing and able to shell out for a given property. This conundrum has left many retailers with a tough choice; be content to accept the lower prices the market will bear for real assets, or try to make do with alternative financing options.

For Cracker Barrel Old Country Store Inc., the $57.6 million the firm added to its coffers via the sale-leaseback of 14 store locations and a retail distribution center in early July trumped the fact that those properties would likely have commanded significantly higher prices just a couple of years ago. Of course, in those days of easy financing, Cracker Barrel probably wouldn’t have needed the cash as much.

Likewise was grocer-turned-United Kingdom’s-biggest-retailer Tesco Plc. willing to accept lower pricing for a seal leaseback deal of its own. When the firm sold off 14 properties under sale leasebacks to a group of institutional and private investors, it got back £431 million for its troubles. Nothing to sneeze at for sure, but still well off the £605 million the firm commanded for a similar deal comprised of 13 properties in August of last year.

While the economy has shown some signs of improvement as of late, retailers aren’t likely to have seen the last of the dark days; just last week, bath and body product maker Crabtree & Evelyn Ltd., which operates 125 U.S. stores, added its name to the list of retailers who have filed for bankruptcy in recent months. For many such troubled firms, sale leasebacks—even for significantly lower proceeds—might be one of the few options left to stay out of the bankruptcy courts.

And, for their part, property investors are certainly taking note of the bargains that can be had as a result of such distress on the part of sellers.

 
Recent Net Leasing Headlines
ProLogis to Develop 554,000-SF BTS Project in the Netherlands
Like so many real estate companies, ProLogis isn't developing spec projects these days, but build-to-suits are a different story. The Denver-based global industrial REIT just agreed to develop a 554,000-square-foot distribution center in The Netherlands for Hi-Logistics, and if ProLogis has anything to do with it, more build-to-suit transactions will materialize.
ProLogis Inks Leases in Baltimore, Japan
Industrial REIT ProLogis has signed two separate lease agreements with tenants in Baltimore and Japan.
Colliers B&K to Head Services for Allstate in Western US
Colliers Bennett & Kahnweiler Inc. has been named transaction management services provider for Allstate Corp.’s Western United States region.
In Supply-Constrained Vancouver Market, 204,000SF Office Trades in Sale Leaseback
In the midst of the sluggish investment market, where most real assets that are selling are on the smaller end of the spectrum, a major office property in Vancouver has been acquired by Kingswood Capital Corp. The 21-story, 204,000-square-foot Grosvenor Building, located in the city’s Downtown, was sold by property investor and developer Grosvenor Americas, which will continue to make its home at the tower under a leaseback agreement.
Net Lease Market Sluggish, But Not Comatose
The net lease marketplace is hardly what it used to be, with deal volume at only a fraction of what it was during the mid-2000s boom years. But net lease never did quite grind to a halt, and there’s some evidence that the market is climbing out of the trough it found itself in during the last quarter of 2008.